Bonton Off-The-Shoulder Cropped Fleece Pullover

Forever 21

Exact color (black), Off-the-shoulder design, Cropped length, Sweatshirt material (fleece), Long sleeves, Loose fit, Similar neckline style (wide boat neck worn off-shoulder), Likely raw hem at neckline and bottom

Miluxas Women's Off The Shoulder Oversized Sweatshirt

Walmart - Miluxas

Exact color (black), Off-the-shoulder style (general), Cropped length, Oversized fit, Sweatshirt material

Aeropostale Women's Cloud Soft Oversized Sweatshirt

Aeropostale.com

Exact color (black), Off-the-shoulder style (via wide boat neck), Oversized fit, Sweatshirt material ('Cloud Soft')