Thin Plastic Headband Set of 8

Walmart - Heads Up Headcare LLC

Exact match for 'thin' profile, Exact match for 'black' color, Exact match for 'headband' category, Simple, unadorned design matches the subtle appearance in the frame, Material (plastic) is consistent with the visual lack of texture/sheen in the frame, High priority retailer (Walmart)

Skinny Matte Headbands

Threddies

Thinness of the headband, Black color, Matte appearance, Fabric-covered material

PandaHall Plastic Cloth Hair Bands

PandaHall.com

Thinness of the headband, Black color, Appears to be fabric-covered, consistent with 'cloth covered'