NYX Retractable Lip Liner

NYX Professional Makeup

Product category (lip liner), Retractable mechanism matches exactly, Solid-colored casing matching the lip liner shade, Brown-nude color is a very close match, Overall form factor and design are highly consistent, High priority retailer (NYX Professional Makeup)

Milani Color Statement Lipliner

Milani Cosmetics

Traditional pencil form factor, Brownish-nude color, Solid casing color matches frame, Appropriate product category

e.l.f Cream Glide Lip Liner

Target

Traditional pencil form factor, Brownish-nude color, Solid casing color matches frame, Appropriate product category