Steve Madden Men's Alfio Slip-On Loafers

Dillard's

Black color matches exactly, Slip-on loafer style matches, Metallic rectangular ornament (horsebit style) is a strong match, Overall design and form factor are highly similar, Toe shape (chisel/squared) is consistent, Price tier is appropriate for the style, High-priority retailer (Dillard's)

Vance Charles Loafer Men's

Overstock

Black color, Slip-on loafer style, Metallic rectangular bar ornament design and color (dark/gunmetal), Smooth, matte leather/synthetic material appearance, Overall loafer silhouette and sole type

Stacy Adams Men's Kaylor Loafer

Men's Wearhouse

Black color, Slip-on loafer style, Smooth leather appearance